Navigating the Turbulent Waters of ESG Funds: Insights from a Challenging Quarter

Welcome back! Are sustainable investment funds losing their momentum? Some might jump to that conclusion based on a disappointing new set of data, but it’s essential to keep the situation in perspective, as I will explain below.

Sustainable investing

A disappointing quarter for green funds — let’s keep it in perspective

The latest statistics for the sustainability-centric fund sector show unsatisfactory results.

According to Morningstar, global net outflows from these funds reached an unprecedented $8.6 billion during the first quarter of this year. Alarmingly, even Europe — the leading region for these funds — experienced negative inflows for the first time since Morningstar began tracking this data in 2018.

While it may seem like the boom times for this segment of investments have passed, it’s crucial to maintain some perspective.

Firstly, this past quarter was, to say the least, unusual. Even the most optimistic green investors could understandably feel unsettled after Donald Trump’s return to the White House, which injected a new level of uncertainty into sustainable investing strategies.

Indeed, inflows into sustainable funds have been declining since the peak year of 2021, when they saw $645 billion in net inflows. Last year, these funds experienced weaker inflows than the broader fund market for the first time, according to Morningstar’s records. However, they still attracted positive net flows — including $18.1 billion in the last quarter of 2024, which was more than double this quarter’s deficit.

It’s also worth noting that these funds’ positive inflows last year were largely due to Europe. In the U.S., outflows have been occurring since late 2022, and negative flows were also recorded in Japan and China last year. However, Europe has consistently been the main driver in this space. At the end of 2021, Europe made up 81 percent of sustainable fund assets, while the U.S. represented just 13 percent.

The fact that this fund sector has faced its first quarter of negative flows in Europe is certainly noteworthy. Nevertheless, the total amount of money involved is not substantial. European sustainable funds saw a net outflow of $1.2 billion, which is just 0.04 percent of their $2.68 trillion in assets at the beginning of the quarter.

Additionally, sustainable fund flows are still positive this year in medium-sized markets, including Canada, Australia, South Korea, and Taiwan. This isn’t a global disaster.

The overall numbers obscure important variations among different types of “sustainable” funds (Morningstar’s data includes numerous funds that claim to center on sustainability, impact, or environmental, social, and governance factors). While equity funds dominate this sector, sustainable fixed-income funds have been enjoying sustained strong inflows — including $14 billion in this quarter — as the green bond market continues to expand.

By the end of this year, we’ll have a clearer view of the medium-term direction of this sector. Recent investment performance suggests some grounds for optimism. Despite the outflows, sustainable funds seem to have maintained their overall asset values slightly better than the broader market during the first quarter’s upheaval. Their total assets decreased by 0.7 percent, compared to a 1.4 percent drop for the Morningstar Global Market index.

None of this ignores the significant challenges this sector faces, particularly in the United States. However, with more than $3 trillion in assets under management, these funds have established themselves as a crucial aspect of the global investment landscape. It will take far worse quarters than this to alter that reality.

Recommended reads

Powering up Clean energy is vital for the U.S. to compete with China in the AI sector, according to former Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson.

Rule rethink Private credit firms are contemplating changes to their sustainability guidelines to allow lending to European defense companies.

New order U.S. oil giant ExxonMobil is poised to surpass European counterparts Shell and BP in low-carbon investment.